Published on: 17th October 2024
Authored by: Pratham Mishra
JINDAL GLOBAL LAW SCHOOL
Introduction
The United Nations (UN)[1] is a cornerstone of global diplomacy and cooperation, established in 1945 in the wake of World War II[2]‘s devastation. Its creation marked a significant shift in international relations, aiming to prevent the recurrence of such a catastrophic conflict by fostering peace and security among nations. Unlike its predecessor, the League of Nations[3], which failed to avert the Second World War, the UN was founded on a stronger legal framework designed to address and manage global conflicts more effectively.
At the core of the UN’s mission is the maintenance of international peace and security, a goal enshrined in Article 1(1) of the UN Charter[4]. This mission is broad and multifaceted, encompassing everything from preventing conflicts and mediating disputes to authorizing peacekeeping missions and enforcing international law through collective action when necessary. Over the decades, the UN has been at the forefront of numerous global peace efforts, dealing with both interstate conflicts and internal crises involving non-state actors.
The importance of the UN’s role in peace and security cannot be overstated. It has been instrumental in resolving disputes between countries and managing complex conflicts within states. However, the UN’s effectiveness has often been challenged by various issues, such as the veto power wielded by the Security Council’s permanent members, inconsistent application of international law, and the intricate web of geopolitical rivalries.
This article will explore the legal framework that underpins the UN’s efforts to maintain peace and security. It will examine the functions of the UN’s various organs, the legal tools at its disposal, and the contemporary challenges it faces. Through this analysis, we aim to gain a deeper understanding of how the UN contributes to global stability and the ways it can adapt to an ever-evolving international landscape.
The UN Charter and the Legal Framework for International Peace and Security
The UN Charter is the cornerstone of the United Nations, guiding its efforts to maintain international peace and security. Established in 1945[5], right after the end of World War II[6], the Charter lays out the UN’s core purposes and principles, with a strong focus on promoting peace and preventing conflicts.
Legal Foundation
Article 1(1) of the UN Charter[7] is clear and direct: the main goal of the United Nations is “to maintain international peace and security.” This fundamental principle underscores the importance of collective action to tackle threats to global peace and to address acts of aggression. It represents a commitment from the international community to work together to prevent conflicts from spiraling into larger, more destructive wars. By providing a framework for cooperation, diplomacy, and peaceful resolution of disputes, the Charter enables the UN to act as a central platform for addressing global security challenges.
The Security Council’s Role
The Security Council[8], as outlined in Chapter VII[9] of the Charter, holds a pivotal role in upholding international peace and security. Articles 39 to 51 empower the Council to identify threats to peace, breaches of peace, or acts of aggression, and to take appropriate actions[10]. These measures can range from economic sanctions and diplomatic efforts to, as a last resort, military intervention. The Security Council is unique among UN bodies in its authority to authorize such interventions, including peacekeeping missions, making its role crucial in addressing and managing conflicts. Its decisions are binding on all member states, reflecting its central position in global security efforts.
Peaceful Settlement of Disputes
Chapter VI[11] of the Charter promotes the peaceful resolution of disputes. Articles 33 to 38 encourage states to resolve their conflicts through methods like negotiation, mediation, arbitration, or judicial settlement[12]. The International Court of Justice[13] (ICJ) plays a significant role in this process, offering legal judgments and advisory opinions that help clarify and resolve state disputes. This emphasis on peaceful dispute resolution supports the UN’s broader mission of maintaining global order through non-violent means.
The Role of the Security Council
The Security Council is the UN’s central organ for maintaining international peace and security. It’s made up of 15 members[14]: five permanent members (the P5)[15]—the United States, the United Kingdom, France, Russia, and China—and ten non-permanent members elected for two-year terms. The Council has significant authority under the UN Charter to address global conflicts, and its decisions often have far-reaching effects on international relations. However, the Council’s role is frequently debated due to the influence of the P5’s veto power[16] and challenges in effectively implementing its resolutions.
Veto Power
One of the most influential aspects of the Security Council’s authority is the veto power[17] held by its five permanent members. This power allows any of the P5 members[18] to block substantive resolutions, including those related to peacekeeping and military actions, by casting a negative vote. While the veto was designed to ensure that major powers stay committed to the Council’s decisions, it has often led to criticism for hindering timely and effective responses. The frequent use of the veto reflects the strategic interests of these major powers rather than the collective needs of the global community, sometimes resulting in inaction or delays in addressing critical crises.
Resolutions and Interventions
The Security Council’s resolutions have significantly impacted global conflicts. For example, Resolution 678 in 1990[19] authorized the use of force to expel Iraqi forces from Kuwait during the Gulf War, and Resolution 1973 in 2011[20] sanctioned military intervention in Libya to protect civilians. However, the effectiveness of these interventions has been mixed. In recent conflicts like the Syrian civil war[21] and the Russian invasion of Ukraine[22], the Council’s ability to act has been limited by political divisions among the P5, leading to constrained or ineffective responses.
Challenges in Implementation
The Security Council faces considerable challenges in implementing its mandates. Geopolitical rivalries and divergent interests among P5 members often result in deadlock on critical issues, undermining the Council’s ability to address conflicts comprehensively. Additionally, the selective enforcement of resolutions—driven by political and strategic considerations—can lead to accusations of bias and ineffectiveness. For instance, the varying responses to conflicts in Syria and Libya highlight how geopolitical interests shape the Council’s actions. These challenges underscore the ongoing debate about reforming the Security Council to enhance its credibility and effectiveness in maintaining global peace.
Peacekeeping Operations
Peacekeeping[23] is one of the United Nations’ most visible and impactful activities, designed to uphold international peace and security. Since its inception, peacekeeping has evolved to address the growing complexity of global conflicts. It involves deploying UN personnel to conflict zones to help establish and maintain peace, typically after a ceasefire has been reached. Over the decades, peacekeeping has transformed significantly, reflecting shifts in global security dynamics.
History and Evolution
UN peacekeeping began with the United Nations Truce Supervision Organization[24] (UNTSO) in 1948, tasked with monitoring a ceasefire between Israel and its neighbouring Arab states[25]. This initial mission set the stage for future peacekeeping efforts, which were originally limited to observational roles with lightly armed troops. As global conflicts grew more complex, so did peacekeeping operations. The 1990s marked a shift towards more robust missions that combined military and civilian efforts, not only to maintain peace but also to aid in post-conflict reconstruction and governance.
Legal Basis for Peacekeeping
The legal basis for UN peacekeeping is rooted in Chapters VI[26] and VII[27] of the UN Charter. Chapter VI covers the peaceful resolution of disputes, providing a framework for traditional peacekeeping missions that involve monitoring ceasefires with the consent of the host state. Chapter VII, however, allows for more assertive actions, including the use of force, if the Security Council identifies a threat to peace or an act of aggression. Modern peacekeeping often blends these approaches, incorporating both traditional observation and more proactive enforcement measures.
Success Stories and Limitations
UN peacekeeping has seen notable successes, such as the missions in Namibia and East Timor. In Namibia, the UN Transition Assistance Group (UNTAG)[28] helped oversee free elections and facilitated the country’s transition to independence from South Africa. Similarly, in East Timor, the UN Mission in East Timor (UNAMET)[29] and subsequent operations supported a successful transition to independence from Indonesia. However, not all missions have been successful. The UN missions in Rwanda and Bosnia during the 1990s[30] faced severe criticism for their failure to prevent genocide and ethnic cleansing, hindered by limited resources and unclear mandates.
Reforms and Modern Challenges
Today’s peacekeeping operations face significant challenges, including limited resources and ambiguous mandates that can lead to inefficiencies. The rise of non-state actors and complex conflicts requires modern peacekeeping to adapt continuously. The UN has initiated reforms to address these issues, such as improving mission planning and training. Despite these efforts, the success of peacekeeping missions depends on robust international support and the ability to navigate the complexities of contemporary conflicts.
While UN peacekeeping remains a vital tool for maintaining international peace and security, it must continuously adapt to address the complexities of modern conflicts and the limitations of its existing framework.
The Role of Other UN Organs in Peace and Security
The General Assembly
The UN General Assembly[31] (GA) has a unique but more indirect role in maintaining international peace and security compared to the Security Council[32]. While the Security Council takes the lead in addressing immediate threats, the GA contributes through debates, resolutions, and recommendations that reflect the collective voice of the global community. Although its resolutions aren’t legally binding, they carry significant moral and political weight. A key example is the “Uniting for Peace” resolution from 1950[33], which empowers the GA to step in and make recommendations on peace and security matters if the Security Council is blocked by a veto or lacks consensus. This mechanism allows the GA to address urgent issues and mobilize international opinion, providing an alternative path for conflict resolution when the Security Council is at an impasse.
International Court of Justice (ICJ)
The International Court of Justice[34] (ICJ) is the UN’s principal judicial body and plays a crucial role in resolving legal disputes between states. Established under the UN Charter, the ICJ provides advisory opinions on legal questions posed by the Security Council, General Assembly, or other authorized UN bodies. Its judgments help maintain international order by reinforcing the rule of law and offering a legal framework for resolving conflicts. Through its work, the ICJ clarifies and interprets international law, promoting stability and predictability in global relations. By providing a forum for legal disputes and offering authoritative legal opinions, the ICJ supports the broader goal of international peace and security.
UN Agencies
Several specialized UN agencies also play important roles in fostering peace and security, albeit in indirect ways. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)[35] addresses the needs of refugees and internally displaced persons, helping to alleviate the humanitarian impact of conflicts and contributing to stability by providing protection and assistance. United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO)[36] promotes international cooperation in education, science, and culture, fostering mutual understanding and reducing tensions between communities. United Nations International Children’s Emergency Fund (UNICEF)[37] focuses on the welfare of children, working to combat poverty, inequality, and human rights abuses, which are often underlying causes of conflict. These agencies, through their specialized mandates and programs, address fundamental issues and contribute to the broader goal of global peace and security.
The Challenges Facing the UN in Maintaining Peace and Security
Geopolitical Conflicts
The geopolitical landscape has transformed dramatically from the Cold War[38] to the present day. During the Cold War, global peace and security were largely dictated by the rivalry between the United States and the Soviet Union. Their opposing interests and influence created a relatively stable but divided world order, with the Security Council reflecting this binary conflict. Decisions were often shaped by the competing priorities of these superpowers, which sometimes resulted in a stalemate on global issues.
Today’s multipolar world presents a more complex and dynamic environment. With multiple powerful states and regional actors, shifting alliances, and deep economic interdependencies, international relations have become more intricate and unpredictable. This new geopolitical reality has introduced heightened competition and fragmentation, complicating the UN’s ability to address global conflicts effectively. The Security Council often struggles to manage these diverse and sometimes conflicting interests, leading to inefficiencies and, at times, inaction in addressing critical issues.
Non-State Actors and Terrorism
The rise of non-state actors and transnational terrorism has emerged as a major challenge for the UN. Groups like ISIS[39] (Islamic State of Iraq and Syria) operate beyond traditional state boundaries, exploiting weak governance and ongoing conflicts to further their objectives. In response, the UN has strengthened its counter-terrorism efforts, adopting various Security Council resolutions aimed at disrupting terrorist financing, restricting the movement of terrorists, and fostering international cooperation. However, the decentralized and adaptable nature of these groups challenges traditional state-centric approaches, requiring a more nuanced and coordinated international strategy.
Reform Proposals
There is an ongoing debate about the need for reform within the UN, particularly concerning the Security Council. Critics argue that the current structure, especially the veto power held by the five permanent members (P5), is outdated and impedes the Council’s ability to address modern issues effectively. Proposed reforms include expanding the number of permanent and non-permanent members to better reflect current global power dynamics and revising or abolishing the veto power to facilitate more equitable decision-making. Despite numerous discussions and proposals, reaching consensus on these reforms remains difficult, largely due to the divergent interests of member states and the reluctance of P5 members to relinquish their veto power. These debates highlight the need for a reformed approach to enhance the UN’s capacity to tackle global peace and security challenges more inclusively and effectively.
Conclusion
Since its creation, the United Nations has made significant strides in maintaining international peace and security. The UN Charter has guided successful interventions, peacekeeping missions, and conflict resolutions, including notable successes in Namibia and East Timor and the role of the International Court of Justice in resolving state disputes. These achievements highlight the UN’s vital role in global diplomacy.
Yet, the UN faces challenges. The Security Council’s effectiveness is often hindered by geopolitical rivalries, and non-state actors and terrorism complicate traditional peace and security approaches.
Looking forward, the UN must adapt to new threats beyond state-based conflicts. The rise of cyber warfare, climate change, and mass migration demands innovative solutions and stronger international cooperation. Improving cybersecurity, incorporating climate strategies into peace and security efforts, and developing comprehensive migration management are crucial for the UN to remain effective.
By addressing these evolving challenges, the UN can maintain its role in global stability and continue to impact the world stage positively.
References:
[1] United Nations, About United Nations, https://www.un.org/en/about-us (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[2] Thomas A. Hughes & John Graham Royde-Smith, World War II | Facts, Summary, History, Dates, Combatants, & Causes, Encyclopedia Britannica (Aug. 23, 1998), https://www.britannica.com/event/World-War-II.
[3] The League of Nations | The United Nations Office at Geneva, The United Nations Office at Geneva, https://www.ungeneva.org/en/about/league-of-nations/overview (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[4] The Charter of The United Nations, art. 1(1)
[5] United Nations, About United Nations, https://www.un.org/en/about-us (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[6] Thomas A. Hughes & John Graham Royde-Smith, World War II | Facts, Summary, History, Dates, Combatants, & Causes, Encyclopedia Britannica (Aug. 23, 1998), https://www.britannica.com/event/World-War-II.
[7] The Charter of The United Nations, 1945, art. 1(1)
[8] Homepage | Security Council, United Nations, https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[9] The Charter of The United Nations, 1945
[10] The Charter of The United Nations, 1945
[11] The Charter of The United Nations, 1945
[12] The Charter of The United Nations, 1945
[13] The Court | INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE, Cour internationale de Justice – International Court of Justice | INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE, https://www.icj-cij.org/court (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[14] Current Members | Security Council, United Nations, https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en/content/current-members (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[15] Current Members | Security Council, United Nations, https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en/content/current-members (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[16] Voting System | Security Council, United Nations, https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en/content/voting-system (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[17] Voting System | Security Council, United Nations, https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en/content/voting-system (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[18] Current Members | Security Council, United Nations, https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en/content/current-members (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[19] September 2024 Monthly Forecast : Security Council Report (Nov. 28, 1990), https://www.securitycouncilreport.org/atf/cf/%7B65BFCF9B-6D27-4E9C-8CD3-CF6E4FF96FF9%7D/Chap%20VII%20SRES%20678.pdf.
[20] S/RES/1973 (2011) | Security Council, United Nations (Mar. 17, 2011), https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en/s/res/1973-(2011).
[21] The Eds. of Encyclopaedia Britannica, Syrian Civil War | Facts & Timeline, Encyclopedia Britannica (July 6, 2011), https://www.britannica.com/event/Syrian-Civil-War.
[22] Russia-Ukraine War | Human Rights Watch, Human Rights Watch | Defending Human Rights Worldwide, https://www.hrw.org/tag/russia-ukraine-war (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[23] United Nations: Peace & Security, United Nations, https://www.un.org/en/peaceandsecurity?gad_source=1&gclid=Cj0KCQjwrp-3BhDgARIsAEWJ6SxsVB9a4aNhTvrem7ik0Czal2XqeN3vmIfSohcloyCHVrtP0QyO9_MaAmXoEALw_wcB (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[24] Background, UNTSO, https://untso.unmissions.org/background (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[25] The Eds. of Encyclopaedia Britannica, Arab-Israeli wars | History, Conflict, Causes, Summary, & Facts, Encyclopedia Britannica (July 20, 1998), https://www.britannica.com/event/Arab-Israeli-wars.
[26] The Charter of The United Nations, 1945
[27] The Charter of The United Nations, 1945
[28] UNTAG, United Nations Peacekeeping, https://peacekeeping.un.org/sites/default/files/past/untagFT.htm (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[29] UNMIT Background – United Nations Integrated Mission in Timor-Leste, United Nations Peacekeeping, https://peacekeeping.un.org/mission/past/unmit/background.shtml (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[30] UNMIBH: United Nations Mission in Bosnia Herzegovina – Background, United Nations Peacekeeping, https://peacekeeping.un.org/mission/past/unmibh/background.html (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[31] General Assembly of the United Nations, United Nations, https://www.un.org/en/ga/ (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[32] Homepage | Security Council, United Nations, https://main.un.org/securitycouncil/en (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[33] What is the Uniting for peace resolution? – Ask DAG!, Ask DAG and find answers about the United Nations and the library resources! – Ask DAG!, https://ask.un.org/faq/177134#:~:text=General%20Assembly%20resolution%20377(V,call%20an%20emergency%20special%20session. (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[34] The Court | INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE, Cour internationale de Justice – International Court of Justice | INTERNATIONAL COURT OF JUSTICE, https://www.icj-cij.org/court (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[35] About UNHCR | UNHCR India, UNHCR India, https://www.unhcr.org/in/about-unhcr (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[36] UNESCO in brief, UNESCO : Building Peace through Education, Science and Culture, communication and information, https://www.unesco.org/en/brief (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[37] About UNICEF, UNICEF, https://www.unicef.org/about-unicef (last visited Sept. 9, 2024).
[38] The Eds. of Encyclopaedia Britannica, Cold War | Summary, Causes, History, Years, Timeline, & Facts, Encyclopedia Britannica (July 20, 1998), https://www.britannica.com/event/Cold-War.
[39] The Eds. of Encyclopaedia Britannica, Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant (ISIL) | History, Leadership, & Facts, Encyclopedia Britannica (Oct. 1, 2014), https://www.britannica.com/topic/Islamic-State-in-Iraq-and-the-Levant.
