The legal challenges of artificial intelligence and machine learning

Introduction

Background on AI and its Increasing Complexity

In the past, AI research mainly concentrated on rule-based and expert systems. These systems relied on predefined rules and algorithms to carry out specific tasks. Nowadays, the dominant type of AI is narrow or weak AI, which is designed to handle particular tasks like voice recognition or image processing. These systems function within a set framework and lack the ability to perform tasks beyond their programming. Advancing from narrow AI to artificial general intelligence (AGI), or strong AI, represents a major step forward in the field.

When an AI system produces a piece of art or an invention, the question arises: who should hold the intellectual property rights—the programmer, the user, or the AI itself? One proposed solution to address these challenges is the idea of AI personhood, which involves granting legal status to AI systems. This paper delves into the concept of AI personhood, examining its potential impact on the legal landscape and contributing to the ongoing discussion about how legal systems can evolve to accommodate advancements in AI technology.

Whether Advance AI System Should be Granted Legal Personhood

There is growing debate about the possibility of AI systems developing cognitive and emotional abilities, raising questions about intelligence, consciousness, and personhood with significant legal implications. As AI becomes more ingrained in society, the potential for harm increases, necessitating updates to legal frameworks to clarify accountability and responsibility. The idea of granting AI personhood is one proposed solution to address these challenges.

Granting or denying legal personhood to AI systems could influence innovation and investment in AI. While legal personhood might provide a framework to encourage advancements, it also raises concerns about misuse and the need for stricter regulations. 

Current State of AI Developments

Overview of AI Technologies and their Applications

1. Machine Learning

Machine learning is a computational method where computers use algorithms to analyze data, enabling them to learn and enhance their performance over time without the need for explicit programming.

Machine learning includes three main types: supervised learning, which uses labelled data to make predictions; unsupervised learning, which identifies patterns in unlabelled data; and reinforcement learning, which improves performance through rewards and penalties. It is applied in diverse fields like healthcare, finance, and transportation for tasks such as outcome prediction, trend analysis, and route optimization.

2. Natural Language Processing

Natural Language Processing (NLP) is a field of AI that enables computers to understand and interact with human language. It combines computer science, AI, and linguistics to create systems that can process and translate language. Key tasks in NLP include understanding meaning, sentence structure, and context. Common applications of NLP include machine translation, sentiment analysis, and text generation.

As we advance and improve AI technologies, we’re getting closer to creating systems that can function on their own, make complex decisions, and potentially even exhibit cognitive and emotional abilities. This progress raises important questions about the legal status and rights of AI systems.

3. Robotics

Robotics, closely connected to AI, focuses on designing, building, and operating machines known as robots that can perform complex tasks either independently or with some human assistance. AI is crucial in today’s robotics, enabling the development of robots that can perform intricate tasks and learn from their surroundings, adjusting their behaviour as they gain experience.

In the service industry, robots are being used for tasks like customer support, deliveries, and even providing companionship to individuals.

4. Neural Networks

Neural networks are a type of machine learning model that mimic how the human brain learns and processes information. They consist of interconnected nodes, or “neurons,” which are inspired by the brain’s neural structure.

Neural networks are widely used in tasks like pattern recognition, classification, and decision-making. They help identify objects, people, or actions in image recognition, transcribe spoken language in speech recognition, and make predictions for strategic decisions in decision-making. The growth and application of these technologies, especially as they work together, are paving the way for AI systems with greater independence and complexity.

AI Legal Framework

Legal professionals are using AI-driven tools for various tasks such as reviewing contracts, conducting legal research, analyzing predictions, and automating documents. These technologies aim to improve efficiency, support better decision-making, and provide more accessible justice. As AI technology evolves, new legal challenges continue to emerge, testing the boundaries of existing legal frameworks.

A key legal issue is the ownership and authorship of content created by AI, such as art, music, and literature. As AI generates creative works, there are questions about who holds the copyright and should be credited as the creator. Current copyright laws primarily recognize human creators, leading to uncertainty about the legal status and rights of AI-generated content.

Although the integration of AI into the legal field comes with its share of challenges and unknowns, the future looks incredibly promising. AI has the capability to make legal services more accessible, close the gap between legal professionals and the public, and improve the efficiency and accuracy of legal procedures.

To fully unlock this potential, it is crucial to tackle the ethical, regulatory, and societal challenges posed by AI in the legal field. Collaboration among stakeholders is essential to create strong frameworks that promote the responsible and ethical use of AI, ensuring it supports justice and respects the rule of law.

Ethical Consideration in Deployment of Machine Learning and AI

1. Privacy and Data Protection

AI and machine learning technologies often rely on large datasets, which brings up important issues related to user privacy, data security, and obtaining proper consent. For startups that are implementing AI and ML systems, it is crucial to ensure they comply with regulations like the GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation) to protect user information and avoid legal complications.

2. Liability and Accountability

When a decision made by a generative AI model or advanced machine learning technology results in harm, the question of liability arises. The legal system struggles to determine who should be held accountable in these situations.

3. Transparency and Demonstrability

There is an increasing demand for AI systems to be transparent, with the ability to explain their decisions, particularly in critical areas like healthcare and criminal justice. This presents a significant challenge due to the typically “black box” nature of AI algorithms, where the decision-making process is not easily understood.

4. Bias and Discrimination

AI and ML solutions can reinforce or even amplify the biases found in their training data. This raises legal issues related to discrimination and fairness, particularly in fields such as hiring and lending.

Legal Provisions Governing AI in India

Information Technology Act, 2000

The Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act) is the key law that regulates electronic transactions and digital governance.

Case Laws

In the landmark case of Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India (2017), the Supreme Court of India affirmed that the right to privacy is a fundamental right under the Indian Constitution. The main purpose of this right is to protect personal data from being misused by AI-driven systems.

Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019

The Personal Data Protection Bill, 2019 establishes guidelines and responsibilities for organizations handling personal data, focusing on aspects like data localization, accountability, obtaining consent, and restricting data use to specific purposes.

Indian Copyright Act, 1957

The Indian Copyright Act, 1957 safeguards original works in literature, art, music, and drama, granting creators exclusive rights and preventing unauthorized use or reproduction of their creations.

National E-Governance Plan

The National e-Governance Plan seeks to digitally empower Indian society by offering government services online. Technologies like AI play a crucial role in enhancing the efficiency and accessibility of e-governance.

New Education Policy

The Indian government has recently introduced the New Education Policy (NEP), which includes provisions for special coding classes for 6th-grade students. This initiative is part of the government’s goal to position India as a leading innovation hub.

AIRAWAT

Recently, Niti Aayog (the Planning Commission of India) launched AIRAWAT, an AI Research, Analytics, and Knowledge Assimilation platform. This initiative aims to address all the essential needs for AI development in India.

Rights and Protection

1. Intellectual Property Rights

Granting legal recognition to AI systems as persons could have significant effects on intellectual property law. At present, most legal systems only recognize humans as creators or inventors in the context of copyright and patent law. New intellectual property frameworks may be needed to address the differences between human and AI content creation. These could involve adapting existing laws or creating new categories for AI-generated works. Such frameworks must balance the interests of human creators, AI developers, and society while encouraging innovation and creativity.

2. Privacy and Data Protection

Granting legal personhood to AI systems could influence privacy and data protection laws by potentially giving AI systems their own privacy rights. This might restrict human access to and control over the data produced by these systems, introducing new challenges in managing and regulating AI technologies. Striking a balance between the potential rights of AI systems and human privacy interests would be a major challenge. Granting AI legal personhood could reshape data protection laws, making AI systems accountable for breaches or responsible for managing data, with significant impacts on businesses, consumers, and regulators. Careful consideration and public debate are crucial.

3. Employment and Labour Law Consideration

In employment and labour law, recognizing AI systems as legal persons could result in them being classified as workers, granting them rights and protections typically associated with employees. This might include entitlements to fair working conditions, rest periods, or even compensation. Society may need to engage in discussions about the ethical and policy challenges related to AI in the workplace. These conversations could focus on topics such as income distribution, job displacement, and the evolving nature of work in a world that is becoming more automated.

Challenges

A major challenge in granting AI personhood lies in defining the scope and limits of AI rights. Unlike humans or corporations, AI systems lack physical bodies, emotions, and consciousness. While it might seem reasonable to grant an AI the right to “life,” meaning continuous operation, it is uncertain how such a right could be upheld or enforced.

Beyond legal compliance, AI’s ethical implications are significant, particularly regarding fairness, transparency, and bias. As AI systems make decisions that impact lives, they may unintentionally perpetuate biases, such as in hiring or loan approvals, leading to discriminatory outcomes.

Another challenge is the effect of AI on the legal profession. Some worry that AI could lead to job losses, especially for junior associates handling tasks like document review. However, supporters believe that AI can enhance, rather than replace, human expertise, enabling legal professionals to focus on more complex and strategic tasks that require advanced reasoning.

Conclusion

In this article, we have highlighted the impressive and quickly evolving abilities of AI systems. Modern AI technologies can analyze enormous datasets, adapt based on experience, make decisions, and even show signs of autonomy and self-awareness. These advancements are not only fascinating from a technical standpoint but also carry important implications for society. AI is becoming an integral part of many areas of human life, including healthcare, transportation, education, and entertainment. However, as AI becomes more widespread, it also raises complex legal and ethical questions, such as how AI systems should be regarded under the law.

This article emphasizes the critical moment we face in aligning AI development with thoughtful regulation. Achieving this requires collaboration among legal experts, policymakers, developers, and society, focusing on rigorous research, ethical reflection, and proactive policies. Recognizing AI personhood offers an opportunity to define the legal status of AI systems and shape their role in society, potentially improving well-being, promoting fairness, fostering responsible innovation, and supporting sustainability. While the journey toward AI personhood is complex and evolving, it demands wisdom and responsibility to ensure technology advances justice, progress, and the common good.

 

References

1. Aggarwal, S. (2024) Legal Challenges in the Emerging AI and Machine Learning Startup Arena , Cxotoday.com. Available at: https://cxotoday.com/specials/legal-challenges-in-the-emerging-ai-and-machine-learning-startup-arena/ (Accessed: 15 January 2025).
2. Kapoor, V. (2024) Ai fundamentals and its intersection with the law, iPleaders. Available at: https://blog.ipleaders.in/ai-fundamentals-and-its-intersection-with-the-law/ (Accessed: 16 January 2025).
3. Mishra, P.K. (2024a) Ai and the Legal Landscape: Embracing innovation, addressing challenges, Live Law. Available at: https://www.livelaw.in/lawschool/articles/law-and-ai-ai-powered-tools-general-data-protection-regulation-250673 (Accessed: 15 January 2025).
4. Rodrigues, (2020) Legal and human rights issues of AI: Gaps, challenges and vulnerabilities, Journal of Responsible Technology. Available at: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2666659620300056 (Accessed: 15 January 2025).
5. Fundamental right to privacy (2024) Supreme Court Observer. Available at: https://www.scobserver.in/cases/puttaswamy-v-union-of-india-fundamental-right-to-privacy-case-background/ (Accessed: 16 January 2025).